Emerald and Diamond Earrings: How to Choose a Pair
Emerald is softer than diamond, and most emeralds have been treated to improve how they look. Both facts point the same way: earrings are one of the best places to wear an emerald, because earrings take far fewer knocks than rings.
This guide covers the styles of emerald and diamond earrings, what to look for in the stone, and how to keep them clean without harming the emerald.
Why earrings suit emerald
GIA rates emerald at 7.5 to 8 on the Mohs scale of hardness. Diamond is 10. GIA also says emeralds are not tough gems to begin with, and suggests saving rings set with less tough gems for special occasions, or setting them in earrings or necklaces.
A ring hits doors, desks and car keys every day. An earring rarely touches anything harder than a hairbrush or a phone. So an emerald that might chip in a ring can last for decades in a pair of studs. If you love emerald and want to wear it every day, start with earrings. Our post on whether emeralds are durable enough for a ring goes into the same question for rings.
Studs: the everyday choice
Studs sit flat against the ear and stay out of the way of scarves, collars and phones. A small emerald stud is easy to wear with anything. Adding a ring of diamonds around the emerald, a halo, makes the earring look larger and adds white sparkle next to the green.
Our Emerald Clover Stud Earrings show both options. The plain pair has four pear-shaped natural emeralds on each earring, set in 18K yellow gold as a four-leaf clover. The second pair adds a frame of small diamonds around the emeralds. If the person you are buying for wears little jewellery, choose the plain pair. If they like more sparkle, choose the diamond frame.

Hoops and huggies
A hoop with emeralds and diamonds set along the front gives you colour from the side as well as from the front. Our Emerald and Diamond Hoop Earrings alternate the two stones in 18K yellow gold.
Check two things on any gem-set hoop. First, the hinge or clasp should close with a firm click. Second, the stones on the inside of the hoop take more contact with the ear and the neck, so they should sit low in the metal. Our post on huggie hoops and hoop earrings explains the sizes.
Colour: what to look for
GIA describes emerald as the bluish green to green variety of beryl, the same mineral family as aquamarine. GIA says the most desirable colours are bluish green to pure green, with vivid colour saturation.
In practice, look at the two earrings side by side in daylight. They should match in colour and in how dark they look. A pair where one stone is bluer or paler than the other is easy to see once they are on. Yellow gold makes green look warmer. White gold makes it look cooler and brighter. Hold both next to your face before you choose.
Inclusions and treatments
Almost every emerald has inclusions, small marks inside the stone. GIA says to expect inclusions that dealers like to call a jardin, French for garden. A clean-looking emerald is rare and priced that way.
Most emeralds are also treated. GIA's emerald care guide says some estimates put the share of fracture-filled emeralds at 90 percent or more, and that the great majority of cut natural emeralds contain filled fractures. The fillers are oils, resins and polymers. Treatment is normal in the trade, and a treated emerald is still a natural emerald. What treatment changes is how you clean it. Our post on lab-created and natural emerald covers the other choice: a stone grown in a lab.

Matching the earrings to a necklace
Emerald earrings pair well with a small emerald pendant in the same metal. The colours do not need to match exactly, since the earrings sit at a distance from the necklace, but the gold should. Mixing a yellow gold pendant with white gold earrings looks deliberate only when you mix metals elsewhere too.
From the Olha New Collection, the Emerald Flower Necklace and the Emerald Halo Pendant are both in 18K yellow gold, like the clover studs and the emerald hoops.
Main points
- GIA rates emerald at 7.5 to 8 on the Mohs scale and says emerald is a less tough gem, so earrings suit it better than rings.
- Studs are the safest daily choice. A diamond halo makes the emerald look larger.
- GIA says the most desirable colours are bluish green to pure green. Match the two stones in daylight.
- Most emeralds are fracture-filled with oils or resins. Clean them with warm soapy water only.
- Emerald is the birthstone for May.
Questions we get asked

Are emerald earrings good for everyday wear?
Yes, earrings are the best way to wear emerald every day. GIA rates emerald at 7.5 to 8 on the Mohs scale, below diamond at 10 and below ruby and sapphire at 9, and it says emeralds are not tough gems to begin with. A ring takes knocks all day from doors, desks, bags and keys, and a hard knock can chip an emerald. Earrings rarely touch anything hard. Studs are the safest style, because they sit flat and do not swing. Take them out before you sleep, swim, shower or exercise, and put them on after makeup, perfume and hairspray, which can dull the stone and work into its fractures. With that care, a pair of emerald studs can be worn every day for years. Bring them in once a year so we can check the settings.
Are the emeralds in earrings usually treated?
Almost always. GIA's emerald care guide says some estimates put the share of fracture-filled emeralds at 90 percent or more, and that the great majority of cut natural emeralds contain filled fractures. The fillers are oils, resins and polymers, which make the small cracks in the stone harder to see. This is normal in the trade and a treated emerald is still a natural emerald. What it changes is the care. Heat, steam and the vibration of an ultrasonic cleaner can push the filler out or weaken the stone, so a treated emerald should be cleaned by hand with warm soapy water. If you want to know about the treatment in a particular stone, ask the seller, and for a large emerald, ask for a lab report that states the type and amount of filler.
How do I clean emerald and diamond earrings?
Use warm water, a drop of mild dish soap and a soft brush. GIA says warm, soapy water with gentle scrubbing is the safest way to clean emeralds, and that it is risky to clean them in an ultrasonic cleaner or with steam. Ultrasonic vibration can weaken stones that already have fractures, and hot steam can make the oil or resin in the fractures sweat out. Soak the earrings for a minute or two, brush gently around the back of each stone where lotion builds up, rinse in clean warm water, and dry with a soft, lint-free cloth. Do not use bleach, ammonia or jewellery dips. The diamonds in the earring do not need anything stronger. If a stone looks dull even after cleaning, bring the pair to us so we can check whether the filler has changed.
Why do emeralds have so many inclusions?
Emerald forms in conditions that leave marks inside the crystal, and those marks are part of what an emerald is. GIA says to expect inclusions in emerald that dealers like to call a jardin, the French word for garden, because the marks can look like moss or branches. Buyers accept many more inclusions in emerald than they would in diamond. The question is how much they affect the look and the strength of the stone. In a small earring stone, a few inclusions are invisible at arm's length. What you want to avoid is a large crack that reaches the surface, since that is a weak spot. Look at each earring under a loupe or in daylight. The colour should be even, and the stone should look bright, with no grey or cloudy areas.
What colour emerald should I choose?
GIA says the most desirable emerald colours are bluish green to pure green, with vivid saturation. Saturation means how strong the colour is. A stone that is too dark looks almost black in dim light, and a stone that is too pale can look like a green glass. A medium to medium-dark green usually shows best in an earring, which people see from across a table. The setting changes the look too. Yellow gold makes green look warmer, while white gold makes it look cooler. Look at the pair in daylight and indoors in the evening, and hold them near the face of the person who will wear them. Above all, the two stones should match each other, because a mismatched pair is easy to notice when they are worn.
Are lab-grown emeralds a good choice for earrings?
They can be. A lab-grown emerald is the same mineral as a natural emerald, beryl, but it is grown in a lab instead of mined. It costs less than a natural stone of the same size and colour, and it has the same hardness, so it wears the same way in an earring. Ask the seller whether the stone has been treated, since that decides how you clean it. People choose natural emerald for its rarity and for the character of its inclusions. People choose lab-grown for the clean look and the lower price. Our post on lab-created and natural sapphire, ruby and emerald compares the two in detail. The product page or receipt should say clearly which type you are buying.
Is emerald a good gift for a May birthday?
Yes. Emerald is the birthstone for May, according to GIA. Earrings are a safe choice for a birthday gift because they need no ring size, and because emerald does better in earrings than in a ring worn every day. A pair of small emerald studs, plain or with a diamond halo, suits most ages and styles. If you know the person wears yellow gold, choose yellow gold, since emerald looks warm and rich in it. If they wear white gold or silver, choose white gold. For a bigger birthday or an anniversary, an emerald pendant to match the earrings makes a set. Our birthstone gift guide covers the other months, and our May birthstone page explains the history of the stone. Include a note on how to clean emerald with the gift.
Can emerald earrings be repaired if a stone falls out?
Yes, a jeweller can set a new emerald, and in many cases can match the colour closely. Matching takes time, because no two emeralds are the same colour, so the jeweller may need to look at several stones. If you still have the stone that came out, keep it in a small bag and bring it in, since resetting the original is simpler than matching a new one. Do not wear the earring while a stone is missing, because the empty prongs or bezel can catch and bend. Setting an emerald needs care: the jeweller cannot use heat near the stone, because heat can damage the filler in its fractures. Vanhess products carry a lifetime repair and maintenance guarantee, as our FAQ page explains, so bring a Vanhess piece to us for any repair.
Sources
- GIA: Emerald gemstone
- GIA: Emerald care and cleaning
- GIA: More Than the Mohs Scale, gem durability
- GIA: Birthstones by month
Checked November 12, 2026. If something here is out of date, tell us and we will fix it.
Visit Vanhess in Coquitlam

To compare emerald colours in daylight, visit Vanhess at 2929 Barnet Highway, Unit 2424, in Coquitlam Centre, or call +1 (604) 653-6449. Our earrings collection and the Olha New Collection both include emerald pieces.













